Ask every customer for a review and never ask for five stars
Regulators and Google object to the same move: deciding which customers get to speak.
The email lands the day after the purchase, and it's friendly. How did we do? Five little faces run from a scowl to a grin. Tap the grin and the next page offers big buttons for Google and Yelp. Tap the scowl and you get a text box for the owner, who'd love to make it right. You've had this email, or one close to it.
The Federal Trade Commission wrote the pattern down in 2023, in the flattest prose a government can manage. In Example 11 of its Endorsement Guides, a marketer surveys recent buyers and invites the delighted ones to post reviews. "Less pleased and unhappy purchasers are simply thanked for their feedback." The verdict is careful: the practice "may be an unfair or deceptive practice if it results in the posted reviews being substantially more positive than if the marketer had not engaged in the practice."
Australia dealt with a cruder version. Meriton, a serviced apartment company, kept guests it expected to complain from receiving TripAdvisor's review prompt, partly by "inserting additional letters into guests’ email addresses". The Federal Court found in 2017 that this misled the public and later ordered A$3 million in penalties.
The filter is the problem
Asking works. BrightLocal, which sells review tools to local businesses, found that 78% of US consumers were asked for feedback in the past year, and 28% say they'll "always" write a review when asked, up from 16% in 2025. Regulators go after the filter in front of the ask: the moment someone with a stake decides which customers get to speak, or what they'll say.
That moment now has a price. The FTC's Consumer Review Rule, in force since October 2024, carries civil penalties of up to $53,088 per violation, unchanged for 2026. It bans incentives tied to a particular sentiment, undisclosed reviews by insiders and certain kinds of review suppression.
In July the FTC finalized an order against TruHeight, a seller of height supplements for children, whose complaint alleged reviews by its own employees and five-star reviews traded for free product. In May, the FTC and the Justice Department alleged that the people behind Premium Home Service, their staff and relatives posted five-star ratings for fake repair businesses.
In March, Britain's Competition and Markets Authority opened five review cases, among them Pasta Evangelists, over undisclosed discounts for five-star reviews. Pasta Evangelists' case was still open in September. Under powers the CMA gained in 2025, it can now fine a company directly, up to 10% of its global turnover.
Line the cases up and they're one mistake: someone with a stake decided what the review would say, by paying for the rating, writing it themselves, hiding the bad ones or keeping the unhappy customer away from the form.
How firmly the gate is ruled out depends on who's reading it. The FTC's Q&A on the Rule says it "does not contain a specific prohibition" on asking only happy customers. "But this practice could violate the FTC Act."
The CMA's guidance calls encouraging only satisfied customers cherry-picking, which may break UK law. Google's Maps policy, a platform rule rather than a law, forbids merchants to "selectively solicit positive reviews from customers".
So the headline is advice. In the US, asking everyone and hoping for five stars is allowed; the FTC's example says inviting every recent buyer is fine "even if it had expressed its hope for positive reviews." Attach a reward to the five stars, even by implication, and you've broken the Rule. The FTC's own example of an implied condition is "Tell us how much you loved your visit to John’s Steakhouse and get a $5 coupon".
Hoping costs nothing. Steering is where the bill arrives.
I got both halves from one salesperson last year, buying my car. Once the sale was done, he told me the manufacturer would probably email me about my experience, and he'd love five stars. That's hoping, and it's allowed. Then he mentioned that the survey might ask whether anyone had requested a five-star rating, and could I do him a favor and say no.
The email came, and the question was on the form. The manufacturer had thought of salespeople like him and written it to catch them, and he'd asked me to lie on it. I don't think I ever filled the form in.
Ask everyone, the same way, every time
Ask every customer through the same channel at the same point, after they've used what they bought. Private feedback can have its own message; the review link goes to everyone, whatever they told you. The survey from the opening email turns harmless the moment the link stops depending on the score.
Leave the rating and the words to the customer. Google lets merchants ask for reviews "without offering incentives to do so or attempting to influence the rating or the contents of the review," and it names staff quotas and requests to mention a staff member as violations. The receipt that says "Mention Dana by name!" breaks the policy, however sweet it looks.
Keep money and staff out of it. The FTC allows an incentive when nothing implies it depends on a good review, and says the review should disclose it; Google bars incentives for any review, so a business that lives on its Maps listing should offer none. Staff who post reviews should say who employs them.
Then keep asking. The CMA lists "arbitrarily stopping and starting review invitations" among the ways a trader can interfere with negative reviews. Asking only after a good month is a gate built out of a calendar.
Publish the bad reviews and answer them as yourself, since BrightLocal found that "Generic or templated replies put off 50% of consumers".
Old praise goes stale
Recency matters too. BrightLocal reports that "74% seek reviews written in the last three months", and 32% want the last two weeks. A review push in the spring loses to asking after every job.
The obvious objection is that asking everyone brings in the twos and threes. It does, and they help. The trust factor at the top of BrightLocal's list, chosen by 56%, is a review that other reviews back up, and agreement means something only when disagreement was possible. To me, a profile with nothing below five stars looks managed.
Nobody has published what dropping the gate does to an average rating, so I can't say how far yours would move. BrightLocal's figures are what shoppers say they do, from a company that profits when reviews matter. The old habit persists: 11% of consumers say they were offered an incentive to write a positive review.
In June I argued that testimonials lose their force once buyers see how cheaply they're made. Reviews are the version of that problem a business can still fix.
The holiday email
Before this season's request goes out, open it as a customer would and rate the experience badly. If the unhappy customer meets a different page, a different question or no link at all, take the difference out. Send the same request to everyone, keep sending it in January, and answer what comes back in your own words.
The good reviews are believable because the bad ones were let in.
More on Craft
Your customers can see the stitches that aren't there
J.Crew's AI catalog passed the glance and failed the people who know how a shirt is cut. The customers who look closest are the ones you lose.
The more an AI avatar mimics a human, the more unsettling it becomes
Coca-Cola swapped people for polar bears and still landed in the uncanny valley. Let your AI look like AI.
Your perfectly mastered podcast now sounds like a bot
How AI audio mastering strips out the one signal that proves a voice is human